YouTube Settles with Trump for $24 Million Over Jan. 6 Suspension Dispute

YouTube Settles Lawsuit with Trump for $24.5 Million

Josh Edelson/AFP for Getty Images

Settlement Details and Implications

In a significant legal resolution, YouTube has agreed to pay $24.5 million to former President Trump, settling a lawsuit from 2021. The lawsuit alleged that YouTube censored Trump by suspending his account following the January 6 Capitol incident. This information was revealed in federal court documents filed recently.

As part of the agreement, Google’s parent company will allocate $22 million towards building a ballroom at the White House, reminiscent of Mar-a-Lago. This project will be funded by the Trust for the National Mall, as outlined in the settlement.

Tech Industry’s Response to Legal Challenges

This settlement is the latest in a series of agreements between tech giants and Trump. Earlier this year, Meta compensated Trump with $25 million over similar account suspensions on Facebook and Instagram. Additionally, Elon Musk’s X, previously known as Twitter, settled for $10 million.

Despite these settlements, free speech experts argue that Trump’s lawsuits lacked substantial legal grounding, as the First Amendment typically protects against government censorship, not actions by private companies. Nonetheless, tech companies have opted for high-profile settlements to conclude these disputes.

Expert Opinions and Industry Reactions

Eric Goldman, a law professor specializing in online speech, criticized the settlements as “influence-peddling,” suggesting they lack legal merit. The White House and Google have not commented on the matter.

Recently, YouTube announced the reinstatement of accounts previously banned for spreading misinformation about COVID-19 and elections. This move aligns with a broader trend of relaxing social media content policies since Trump’s presidency began. Notable accounts reinstated include those of Steve Bannon, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and Dan Bongino.

Legal Protections and Future Implications

The settlements mark a notable shift for Silicon Valley, which has long defended its right to moderate content on its platforms. Section 230, a federal law, grants tech companies significant freedom to manage content without facing legal repercussions.

Goldman emphasized that without the desire to gain favor with Trump, these lawsuits would likely have been unsuccessful. The settlement also includes $2.5 million for other plaintiffs, such as the American Conservative Union and author Naomi Wolf, who faced suspensions for spreading unverified vaccine information.